Assessing reproductive toxicity based on zonagenetic assays of
xenoestrogens, and new concepts concerning animal gestation
B.Th. Walther
Dept. of Molecular Biology, Univ. of Bergen, N-5020 Bergen, NORWAY
Female sexual maturation proceeds by pivotal hepatic biosynthetic processes
under the control of estrogens. In fish, oogenesis involves both zonagenesis and
vitellogenesis, forming the bulk of the eggshell (zona) and yolk, respectievely
(Walther 1993). Estradiol induces mRNAs for zona radiata proteins (zrp;
Oppen-Berntsen et al. 1990) and for vitellogenin (vtg), by interacting with
hepatic estrogen receptor, followed by protein synthesis.
Such inductions also occur in primary cultures of hepatocytes from juvenile
Atlantic salmon, which secrete zrp and vtg into the culture medium (Oppen-Berntsen
et al. 1992). In vivo, zrp and vtg are transported in the blood for
specific uptake by the ovaries (Oppen-Berntsen et al. 1994). Recent evidence
shows that zonagenesis occurs in response to lower levels of estradiol than are
required to initiate vitellogenesis in juvenile Atlantic salmon (Celius &
Walther 1998). Zonagenesis may be initiated already at levels approximating
those sufficient for induction of hepatic estrogen receptor (ER). Furthermore,
at high levels of estradiol, vitellogenesis appears to be somewhat delayed
compared to zonagenesis. The finding of zonagenesis induced at putatively
constitutive ER-levels, points to initiation of puberty by non-classical steroid
signal pathways (Celius & Walther, unpubl.).
In analogy to Sumpter & Jobling (1995), we used in vitro induction of
zonagenesis to assess the estrogenic potential by xenobiotics and mycotoxins (Celius
et al. 1999). Zonagenesis provides an alternate and supplementary assay for
rapid assessment of xenoestrogenicity, as shown in vivo for xenobiotics
such as nonylphenol (Arukwe et al. 1997). Nonylphenol, lindane, bisphenol A, and
DDT, as well as zearalenone, and both isomers of zearalenol, all induced
zonagenesis in vitro, albeit with various potencies. The relative
activities of the zearalenol isomers compared to their in vivo activity.
Results from this assay may rationalize how various xenobiotics, despite their
highly disparate molecular structures (e.g. lindane & DDT), may all exhibit
the biological property of estrogenicity.
Finally, the reproductive relevance of zonagenesis is discussed in the context
of the evolution of vertebrate gestation, and of sexual reproduction (Walther
1993; 1998). Zonagenesis may protect vertebrate gestation in fish, reptiles and
mammals, but zrp-deposition reflects the evolution of the female reproductive
tract (Walther 1999). If zonagenesis exists in all vertebrates, it may be a
common biomarker for xenoestrogenic action in vertebrates. Since zonagenesis was
thought to be more limited than vitellogenesis, this conclusion is surprising.
References
Arukwe, A. et al. (1997) Environ. Health Perspectives 105: 2 - 5.
Celius, T. & Walther, BT (1998) J. Endocrinology 158: 258 - 266.
Celius, T. et al. (1999) Environ. Health Perspectives 107: 63 -
68.
Oppen-Berntsen, DO et al. (1990) Devel. Biology 137: 258 - 265.
Oppen-Berntsen, DO et al. (1992) J. Endocrinology 135: 293 - 302.
Oppen-Berntsen, DO et al. (1994) J. Experimental Zoology 268: 59 -
70.
Sumpter, JP & Jobling, S. (1995) Environ. Health Perspectives
103 (suppl.): 173 - 178.
Walther, BT (1993) Physiol. Biochem. of Fish Larvae,
pp.2-21. U. of Bergen.
Walther, BT (1998) Proc. EMBO Reproduction Workshop. p.14, U. of
Bergen.
Walther. BT (1999) Sarsia (in press).
http://www.eawag.ch/courses/eedc/abstracts.html
|